Kensink Labs
★ Content audit13 rubricsPer-type scoring
CONTENT TYPES · 13 RUBRICS

Different page types fail differently.

A homepage, a pillar page, a product page, and a knowledge-base article should never be audited against the same rubric. This is where the real wins live, and where most generic audits skip straight past. Here are the thirteen rubrics we run.

01 · BRAND · HIGH-TRAFFIC01 / 13

Home page

First impression. Must answer ‘what is this’ in under seven seconds.

Rubric
  • Value proposition understandable in ≤ 7 seconds
  • Primary CTA above the fold: one dominant action
  • Social proof (logos, testimonials, key metrics) visible without scrolling far
  • Clear routing to 3–5 primary site sections
  • Under 2.0s LCP, since this is your highest-traffic page
  • Brand-query ranking: should rank #1 for your own name
Schema · Organization + WebSite
02 · PILLAR · DEFINITIVE02 / 13

Pillar / hub pages

The definitive resource on a topic. Anchors the cluster.

Rubric
  • Comprehensive coverage: aim for ‘definitive resource’ depth
  • Strong internal linking outward to cluster pages, inward from them
  • Table of contents for long-form pillars
  • Target keyword: broad, high-volume, head term
  • Last-updated date visible and recent
  • Answer-ready structure: H2s phrased as questions for key sub-topics
Schema · Article + FAQPage (where relevant)
03 · CLUSTER · LONG-TAIL03 / 13

Cluster / supporting articles

One narrow idea per article. Links to parent pillar + siblings.

Rubric
  • Narrow, specific topic: one idea per article
  • Internal link to parent pillar + sibling cluster pages
  • 800–2,500 words depending on query intent (don’t bloat)
  • Long-tail keyword focus
  • Author byline with credentials (E-E-A-T signal)
  • Published + modified dates
Schema · Article + Author (Person) + BreadcrumbList
04 · PROOF · CREDIBILITY04 / 13

Case studies

Quantified outcomes for named clients. Credibility currency.

Rubric
  • Client name, industry, challenge clearly stated
  • Quantified outcomes: numbers, not vibes
  • Quote from a named client contact
  • Solution narrative with enough detail to be credible, not so much it bores
  • Internal link to relevant solution / service page
Schema · Article (or custom) · Review if client permits
05 · SERVICE · CONVERSION05 / 13

Solution / service pages

One clear problem. Who it’s for. Who it isn’t. Proof. CTA.

Rubric
  • One clear problem it solves, stated upfront
  • Who it’s for, who it’s not for
  • How it works (3–5 steps / diagram)
  • Proof (logos, case studies, metrics)
  • Primary CTA (demo / contact)
  • FAQ section at the bottom with FAQPage schema for questions buyers actually ask
Schema · Service
06 · PRODUCT · COMMERCE06 / 13

Product pages (e-commerce)

Decision page. Price, availability, proof, all visible.

Rubric
  • Clear price, availability, variants
  • High-quality images + zoom + alt text
  • Reviews with AggregateRating schema
  • Specs, dimensions, materials
  • Delivery + return policy visible
  • Related products
Schema · Product + Offer (validated)
07 · PRICING · DECISION07 / 13

Pricing pages

The fork in the funnel. Comparison + trust signals + no dark patterns.

Rubric
  • Tier comparison as a real table
  • Primary action per tier
  • FAQ beneath (billing, trials, cancellation)
  • Trust signals (security, compliance badges)
  • Currency / region handling if international
  • No dark patterns. Auditors should be skeptical of friction and misleading cues
Schema · Offer · Product · custom
08 · HUB · DISCOVERY08 / 13

Blog index / insights hub

Wayfinding. Filter, sort, find the article that matters.

Rubric
  • Filter by topic / tag
  • Reverse-chronological by default, but curated ‘featured’ slot
  • Each card: title, excerpt, author, date, estimated read time
  • Paginated, not infinite scroll (or both)
  • Dedicated RSS feed
Schema · ItemList / Blog
09 · PAID · CAMPAIGN09 / 13

Landing pages (paid campaigns)

Single purpose, single CTA. Message-match the ad.

Rubric
  • Single purpose, single CTA
  • Match the ad creative (message match)
  • No primary nav, so there are no escape hatches
  • Form: minimum necessary fields
  • UTM params handled and persisted
  • Excluded from main sitemap if short-lived; included if evergreen
Schema · WebPage · noindex if appropriate
10 · DOCS · UTILITY10 / 13

Documentation / knowledge base

Get answers fast. Search + hierarchy + feedback loop.

Rubric
  • Search prominent and working
  • Hierarchical left-nav
  • Versioning if applicable
  • Code blocks syntax-highlighted and copyable
  • Each article has a ‘was this helpful?’ feedback mechanism
Schema · TechArticle or Article
11 · TRUST · ENTITY11 / 13

About / team / trust pages

Establish who we are. Entity consistency for AI + search.

Rubric
  • Named leadership with photos, titles, bios, LinkedIn
  • Person schema on each leader
  • Company story with founding date, mission
  • Security / compliance page linked (SOC 2, ISO 27001, GDPR) if B2B
Schema · Organization (foundingDate, founder, address) + Person
12 · LEAD · INTAKE12 / 13

Contact / demo / lead-capture

Convert intent. Multiple modes + clear expectations.

Rubric
  • Multiple contact modes (form, email, phone, chat)
  • Expected response time stated
  • Form validated client-side AND server-side
  • Confirmation message AND confirmation email
  • Accessible form fields with labels
Schema · ContactPage
13 · LEGAL · COMPLIANCE13 / 13

Legal pages (privacy, terms, cookies)

Compliance + linkage. Not for indexing.

Rubric
  • Present, up-to-date, jurisdiction-appropriate
  • Linked from footer of every page
  • Cookie consent mechanism aligned with GDPR / ePrivacy where applicable
  • Not indexed usually (use noindex)
Schema · WebPage (typically noindex)
CONTENT AUDIT · BOOK

Want every URL on your site scored by type?

We inventory every indexed URL, classify it by type, run the matching rubric, and return a prune-keep-merge-rewrite roadmap organized by editorial priority.

Book content audit →